Tax Investigations

HMRC Tax Investigation Solicitors

HMRC Tax Investigations wields broad investigative powers. When facing an investigation both companies and individuals need representation from experienced solicitors and accountants who are well-versed in challenging and negotiating with HMRC.

Regardless of whether you are confronted with a civil tax investigation or a criminal one, our tax investigation solicitors and specialist accountants can provide confidential and cost-effective advice and representation.

HMRC Tax Investigation Solicitors during a client consultation in Manchester.

HMRC Tax Investigation Solicitors & Accountants

Axis Solicitors’ team of tax investigation solicitors and accountants have over 15 years of experience in assisting and defending clients while they are facing HMRC cases. Our HMRC tax investigation solicitors deliver effective legal defence when you need it, whether your case involves tax investigations, tax fraud, or any other allegations concerning an individual’s or business’s declared tax. 

With our record in tackling complicated and tax cases, our results driven experts take pride in defending both high-profile cases and small business owners in Manchester, Birmingham and London with the same dedication and focus.

FAQ: HMRC Tax Investigations

HMRC tax investigations are inquiries conducted by the UK government to ensure compliance with tax laws. These investigations can be civil or criminal in nature, depending on the severity of the suspected offence.

In cases of suspected tax evasion, VAT fraud, or tax fraud, HMRC may launch a criminal investigation if the offence meets specific criteria. While many tax inquiries are civil and can be resolved without criminal penalties, HMRC will escalate to a criminal investigation in situations where:

  • HMRC wants to send a strong deterrent message
  • The behaviour involved warrants criminal sanctions

If found guilty following a criminal investigation, individuals or businesses may face severe financial penalties and, in some cases, imprisonment.

HMRC conducts three primary types of tax investigations: Section 9A enquiries, Code of Practice 8 (COP8), and Code of Practice 9 (COP9). These investigations are not automatically criminal and do not necessarily lead to prosecution. However, HMRC may escalate to a criminal investigation if non-compliance or evidence of serious tax offences is found.

A Section 9A enquiry is an investigation by HMRC to review the information provided on your self-assessment tax return. This type of enquiry can either focus on a specific aspect of your return or be selected at random. Typically, these investigations are conducted through written correspondence with HMRC.

A COP8 investigation is triggered when HMRC suspects tax avoidance or minor tax fraud. These investigations usually involve informal meetings and correspondence between you and HMRC, during which they seek to uncover any underpaid tax.

A COP9 investigation is launched when HMRC suspects serious tax fraud but has not yet initiated a criminal investigation. In this case, you are required to provide a comprehensive report detailing your tax affairs, including any actions—whether intentional or not—that may have caused irregularities. Cooperation is crucial, as it can lead to a reduced penalty once a settlement for unpaid tax and interest is reached.

While Section 9A, COP8, and COP9 investigations are civil, HMRC may escalate the matter to a criminal investigation if they uncover evidence of serious tax fraud or non-compliance. Failure to cooperate during the investigation process can also lead to prosecution.

Your behaviour throughout the investigation plays a significant role in determining the penalty. By being transparent, cooperative, and responding promptly to HMRC’s requests, you can potentially reduce the amount of any penalty imposed.

In most civil tax investigations, you and HMRC can reach an agreement on the amount of tax owed and any penalties, which typically avoids the need to go to court. However, if you are unable to reach a mutual agreement or disagree with HMRC’s decision, you have the option to appeal and initiate litigation in either a civil court or a tribunal.

If HMRC escalates the matter to a criminal investigation and finds evidence of criminal offences, you may need to attend court for criminal prosecution.

If you disagree with the outcome of an HMRC investigation, you have the option to request an internal review. This review is conducted by a different HMRC officer who was not involved in the original case. They can either uphold or adjust the findings of the initial investigation.

If you are still dissatisfied with the decision, you can appeal and initiate the litigation process in a civil court or tribunal. During litigation, both you and HMRC will present evidence supporting your respective tax calculations, and the court or tribunal will determine the correct tax figure. If it is decided that you have underpaid, you will be given a deadline to pay the owed tax, along with interest and any penalties. In some cases, you may be allowed to settle the payments in instalments.

While HMRC often deals with minor tax avoidance and fraud through civil litigation, more serious tax offences can result in criminal prosecution.

Common offences that may lead to prosecution include:

  • Income tax evasion
  • VAT evasion
  • Cheating the public revenue
  • Providing false information or documents to HMRC
  • Smuggling or fraudulently evading excise duties on goods such as alcohol or cigarettes
  • Money laundering

If you are under investigation for any of these offences, seek our legal advice promptly to minimise the risk of prosecution and severe penalties.

In an HMRC tax investigation, you will be required to pay any outstanding tax along with interest calculated from the original due date. The penalties you face will depend on whether your case is handled through civil or criminal litigation.

  • Civil Penalties
    HMRC will negotiate a penalty based on the amount of unpaid tax, whether the missed payment was deliberate, and your level of cooperation during the investigation. If an agreement cannot be reached, the penalty will be determined by a court or tribunal. HMRC may also publicly disclose penalties that exceed certain thresholds.

  • Criminal Penalties
    Criminal prosecution can result in fines, imprisonment, or both. Regardless of the outcome, you will still be required to repay the tax owed and may also be ordered to cover prosecution costs. In serious cases, you could also be prosecuted under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 and the Money Laundering Regulations 2017, which may result in the confiscation of your assets if you are convicted of money laundering.

Tax evasion is treated with great severity, often resulting in substantial penalties. Our solicitors can help you avoid or reduce both civil and criminal penalties.

HMRC Enquiry? We Can Help.

Our HMRC Tax Investigation Solicitors Are On Your Side.

Worried about tax investigations? Benefit from the protection of client privilege with our solicitors and the specialised Tax knowledge of our tax accountants.

Contact us for a confidential discussion.